The test square decides, not the titles. The method is standard: a square of roof is marked, impacts are counted and photographed, and each mark is tested for whether it fractured the shingle mat, which is functional damage, or merely dented and scuffed surfaces, which is cosmetic. Heat-aged shingles complicate it honestly, because an old mat bruises under impacts a new roof would shrug off, which is why the same storm produces different findings on the east side and in Shadow Creek Ranch. Ask both parties to show you their test squares. The one who will not mark a square is arguing, not measuring.
Prefer to talk later? Leave your details and an independent local pro will call you back. No charge to you, no obligation.
Moccasin Lake Roofing is a free referral service. Submitting this form connects you with independent local contractors who provide the work.